Since the Industrial Revolution, humans have released massive amounts of carbon dioxide (COβ) into the atmosphere by burning fossil fuels, deforesting land, and manufacturing goods. The ocean has absorbed approximately 30% of this excess atmospheric COβ, which has fundamentally altered the chemistry of seawater. When COβ dissolves in seawater, it reacts with water molecules to form carbonic acid (HβCOβ). This process lowers the ocean's pH, making it more acidic β a phenomenon scientists call ocean acidification.
The ocean's average surface pH has decreased from approximately 8.2 to 8.1 since pre-industrial times. While this may seem like a small change, the pH scale is logarithmic, meaning this 0.1 decrease represents a roughly 26% increase in hydrogen ion concentration. If current COβ emission trends continue, ocean pH could drop to 7.8 by the year 2100, representing a 150% increase in acidity compared to pre-industrial levels.
This shift in ocean chemistry has profound effects on marine life, particularly calcifying organisms β species that build shells or skeletons from calcium carbonate (CaCOβ). These include corals, oysters, clams, sea urchins, and certain species of plankton called coccolithophores. As ocean pH drops, the concentration of carbonate ions (COβΒ²β») decreases, making it harder for these organisms to build and maintain their calcium carbonate structures. In severely acidic conditions, existing shells and coral skeletons can actually begin to dissolve.
The impacts extend far beyond shell-building species. Ocean acidification disrupts the behavior and physiology of fish, impairs the ability of marine larvae to navigate and settle in suitable habitats, and weakens the structural integrity of coral reefs that provide habitat for approximately 25% of all marine species. Scientists have found that some fish exposed to acidified water exhibit impaired decision-making, reduced predator avoidance, and altered sensory perception. These cascading effects threaten the stability of entire marine ecosystems and the human communities that depend on them for food, economic activity, and coastal protection.
Complete each sentence stem using evidence from the reading passage. Write in complete, detailed sentences.
Procedure: Set temperature to 15Β°C (constant). For each COβ level listed below, record the pH from all four ocean regions.
| COβ (ppm) | π§ Arctic | π Atlantic | ποΈ Pacific | βοΈ Indian |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 280 | ||||
| 560 | ||||
| 1000 |
Procedure: Set COβ to 420 ppm (constant β current levels). For each temperature, record the Arctic and Indian Ocean pH, then calculate the difference.
| Temperature | π§ Arctic pH | βοΈ Indian pH | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5Β°C (Polar) | |||
| 15Β°C (Temperate) | |||
| 25Β°C (Subtropical) | |||
| 35Β°C (Tropical) |
Procedure: Set temperature to 15Β°C. Slowly increase COβ from 280 ppm and watch the Organism Health Monitor. Find the approximate COβ level (ppm) where each organism first changes from Healthy β Stressed, and when it reaches Dissolving.
| Organism | COβ at "Stressed" | COβ at "Dissolving" | Most Sensitive? |
|---|---|---|---|
| πͺΈ Coral Reefs | |||
| π¦ͺ Oysters | |||
| π¦ Sea Urchins | |||
| π¬ Coccolithophores |
Using your data from the three collection rules, complete each sentence stem with specific evidence from your observations.
Ocean acidification does not affect all marine species equally, and its impacts ripple through ecosystems in complex and often unpredictable ways. Pteropods, sometimes called "sea butterflies," are tiny marine snails with thin calcium carbonate shells that are highly vulnerable to acidification. Despite their small size, pteropods are a critical food source for salmon, herring, mackerel, and even whales. Research in the Southern Ocean has shown that pteropod shells are already dissolving in regions where pH has dropped below 8.0, potentially destabilizing food webs that billions of people depend on for protein.
Coral reefs face a double threat: warming waters cause coral bleaching, while acidification weakens the calcium carbonate framework that gives reefs their structure. Without healthy coral, the thousands of species that depend on reef habitat β from clownfish to sea turtles β lose their shelter, breeding grounds, and food sources. Scientists estimate that if ocean pH falls below 7.8, most tropical coral reefs will shift from net growth to net dissolution, meaning they will erode faster than they can rebuild.
The economic consequences are staggering. The global shellfish industry, worth over $20 billion annually, faces declining harvests as oyster larvae fail to form shells in increasingly acidic hatchery waters. In the Pacific Northwest of the United States, oyster farmers have already experienced catastrophic larval die-offs linked to upwelling of acidified deep water. Meanwhile, coral reef tourism generates approximately $36 billion per year worldwide. The loss of these ecosystems would devastate coastal economies, particularly in developing nations where marine resources provide both food security and livelihoods.
In 2007, the Whiskey Creek Shellfish Hatchery in Tillamook Bay, Oregon experienced an unprecedented crisis. Oyster larvae suddenly began dying in massive numbers β production dropped by nearly 80% over two seasons. Scientists discovered that seasonal upwelling events were bringing deep, COβ-rich water to the surface along the Pacific coast. This water, which had absorbed carbon dioxide decades earlier when it sank to the ocean floor, had a pH as low as 7.4 β far below the 8.0 threshold needed for healthy larval development.
Hatchery manager Alan Barton and Oregon State University researcher Burke Hales installed real-time water chemistry monitoring systems. They found that the most corrosive water arrived between midnight and early morning, when offshore winds intensified upwelling. By adjusting their intake schedules to avoid the most acidic water and treating incoming water with sodium carbonate to raise pH, the hatchery was able to recover production. However, wild oyster populations in the bay, which cannot avoid acidic water, continued to show recruitment failures.
| Time | pH | COβ (ppm in water) | Larval Survival |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6:00 AM | 7.4 | 1,200 | 8% |
| 10:00 AM | 7.8 | 680 | 42% |
| 2:00 PM | 8.1 | 380 | 89% |
| 6:00 PM | 8.0 | 420 | 76% |
| 10:00 PM | 7.6 | 950 | 21% |
Complete each of the three statements below by selecting the phrase that correctly describes the data from Whiskey Creek Hatchery. [1]
Statement 1:
The data table shows that the highest larval survival rate of 89% occurred at
Statement 2:
The relationship between COβ concentration and larval survival is best described as
Statement 3:
The hatchery's solution of adjusting water intake times was effective because
Which row in the table below correctly describes the evidence from Whiskey Creek that explains why wild oyster populations continued to decline even after the hatchery recovered?
| Row | Hatchery Adaptation | Wild Population Response | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|
| (1) | Adjusted intake to avoid low-pH water | Cannot avoid acidified water during upwelling | Technological solutions protect controlled environments but not natural ecosystems |
| (2) | Added sodium carbonate to raise pH | Wild oysters produce their own sodium carbonate | Wild oysters will adapt naturally over time |
| (3) | Adjusted intake to avoid low-pH water | Wild oysters migrated to deeper water | Migration is a more effective strategy than water treatment |
| (4) | Added sodium carbonate to raise pH | Cannot avoid acidified water during upwelling | Sodium carbonate is toxic to wild oyster populations |
The Great Barrier Reef, the world's largest coral reef system stretching over 2,300 kilometers along Australia's northeast coast, has experienced five mass bleaching events since 2016. While warming sea surface temperatures trigger the bleaching response β causing corals to expel their symbiotic zooxanthellae algae β ocean acidification compounds the damage by reducing the corals' ability to recover. Healthy coral can regrow after a bleaching event if conditions return to normal within weeks. However, in acidified water with reduced carbonate ion availability, the rate of skeletal regrowth drops by 30β50%, meaning corals take significantly longer to rebuild, leaving them vulnerable to the next bleaching event.
A 2022 survey by the Australian Institute of Marine Science documented that hard coral cover had declined from an average of 28% in 2016 to 12% in localized sections of the northern reef. Researchers measured water pH at reef sites and found values ranging from 8.05 to 7.95 β already below the pre-industrial baseline of 8.16. Dr. Katharina Fabricius of AIMS noted: "We're watching a compounding cycle β warmer water bleaches the coral, and more acidic water slows recovery. Each event leaves the reef weaker than before."
| Year | Hard Coral Cover | Bleaching Event? | Avg pH at Reef |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2015 | 28% | No | 8.08 |
| 2016 | 22% | Yes (severe) | 8.05 |
| 2017 | 15% | Yes (severe) | 8.04 |
| 2020 | 18% | Yes (moderate) | 8.01 |
| 2022 | 12% | Yes (severe) | 7.95 |
Which row in the table below correctly describes the evidence for the compounding cycle affecting the Great Barrier Reef?
| Row | Initial Stress on Coral | Effect of Acidification on Recovery | Long-Term Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| (1) | Warming causes bleaching (loss of zooxanthellae algae) | Reduced carbonate ions slow skeletal regrowth by 30β50% | Each bleaching event leaves reef weaker; coral cover declined from 28% to 12% |
| (2) | Acidification causes bleaching (loss of zooxanthellae algae) | Warming temperatures accelerate skeletal regrowth by 30β50% | Coral adapts and cover stabilizes at 18% |
| (3) | Warming causes bleaching (loss of zooxanthellae algae) | Increased carbonate ions accelerate skeletal regrowth | Reef recovers fully between bleaching events |
| (4) | Acidification causes bleaching (loss of zooxanthellae algae) | Reduced carbonate ions slow skeletal regrowth by 30β50% | Coral cover increases from 12% to 28% over time |
A student uses the data table to make several observations about the Great Barrier Reef. The observations are listed below.
Which set of observations are correctly supported by the data?
In 2014, researchers from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) published a landmark study documenting severe shell damage in Limacina helicina, a species of pteropod collected from the Southern Ocean near Antarctica. Using scanning electron microscopy, the team found that 53% of pteropods collected from surface waters showed signs of shell dissolution β pitting, thinning, and surface erosion that had never been documented at such high rates. The damage was concentrated in regions where surface water pH measured between 7.9 and 8.0.
Pteropods are often called the "potato chips of the sea" because they are consumed by so many species. In Antarctic waters, pteropods can account for up to 60% of the diet of juvenile pink salmon and are a primary food source for zooplankton-feeding whales. NOAA scientist Dr. Nina BednarΕ‘ek estimated that by 2050, if COβ emissions follow current trends, pteropod shell dissolution will affect 70% of the Southern Ocean pteropod population, with potential cascading effects through the entire Antarctic food web β from krill to penguins to seals to orcas.
| pH Range | Pteropods Sampled | % with Shell Damage | Avg Shell Thickness |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8.10 β 8.16 | 120 | 12% | 0.42 mm |
| 8.00 β 8.09 | 95 | 28% | 0.35 mm |
| 7.90 β 7.99 | 140 | 53% | 0.24 mm |
| 7.80 β 7.89 | 60 | 71% | 0.15 mm |
Complete each of the three statements below by selecting the phrase that correctly describes the pteropod data from the Southern Ocean. [1]
Statement 1:
The data shows that as ocean pH decreased from 8.10β8.16 to 7.80β7.89, the percentage of pteropods with shell damage
Statement 2:
Average shell thickness changed from 0.42 mm to 0.15 mm across the pH range, which demonstrates that
Statement 3:
The NOAA prediction that 70% of Southern Ocean pteropods will be affected by 2050 is significant because pteropods
Which row in the table below correctly uses the data to describe the relationship between pH, shell condition, and the potential impact on the Antarctic food web?
| Row | pH Trend | Shell Response | Food Web Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| (1) | pH decreases from 8.16 to 7.80 | Shell damage increases; thickness decreases from 0.42 to 0.15 mm | Reduced pteropod populations lead to declining salmon, herring, and whale populations |
| (2) | pH increases from 7.80 to 8.16 | Shell damage increases; thickness increases from 0.15 to 0.42 mm | Increased pteropod populations lead to overpopulation of salmon and whales |
| (3) | pH decreases from 8.16 to 7.80 | Shell damage decreases; thickness increases from 0.15 to 0.42 mm | Pteropod populations remain stable regardless of pH change |
| (4) | pH increases from 7.80 to 8.16 | Shell damage decreases; thickness decreases from 0.42 to 0.15 mm | Reduced pteropod populations lead to increased krill populations |
An appositive is a noun or phrase placed next to another noun to identify or describe it. Example: "Pteropods, tiny marine snails with thin calcium carbonate shells, are vulnerable to acidification."
Rewrite each sentence by adding an appositive phrase that provides additional detail. Place commas around your appositive.
Use subordinating conjunctions (although, when, if, while, since, unless, before, after) to combine ideas and show relationships between concepts.
Since 1958, scientists at the Mauna Loa Observatory in Hawai'i have continuously measured atmospheric COβ concentration β a record known as the Keeling Curve. Beginning in 1988, the Aloha Station (100 km north of Hawai'i) has measured ocean surface pH at the same location. Together, these two datasets provide direct evidence that rising atmospheric COβ is driving ocean acidification.
| Year | Atmospheric COβ (ppm) | Ocean Surface pH | Avg Global Temp Anomaly (Β°C) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1960 | 317 | 8.120 | +0.02 |
| 1980 | 339 | 8.110 | +0.26 |
| 1990 | 354 | 8.100 | +0.45 |
| 2000 | 369 | 8.085 | +0.39 |
| 2010 | 390 | 8.075 | +0.72 |
| 2020 | 414 | 8.055 | +1.29 |
| 2024 | 425 | 8.045 | +1.45 |
Complete each of the three statements below by selecting the phrase that correctly describes the Mauna Loa and Aloha Station data. [1]
Statement 1:
From 1960 to 2024, as atmospheric COβ increased from 317 ppm to 425 ppm, ocean surface pH
Statement 2:
The rate of COβ increase has accelerated over time. Between 1960 and 1990 COβ rose 37 ppm in 30 years, while between 1990 and 2024 it rose
Statement 3:
A drop of 0.075 pH units (from 8.120 to 8.045) may appear small, but because the pH scale is logarithmic, this represents approximately a
The U.S. shellfish industry generates over $4 billion annually and supports approximately 200,000 jobs in coastal communities. Since the early 2000s, hatcheries and wild harvest operations have documented increasing production failures linked to ocean acidification. The Pacific Northwest β Oregon, Washington, and northern California β has been especially impacted due to seasonal upwelling that brings naturally COβ-rich deep water to the surface, compounding the effects of anthropogenic (human-caused) COβ.
A 2015 NOAA economic analysis estimated that the U.S. shellfish industry could lose $400 million per year by 2060 if COβ emissions continue at current rates. Communities in Maine, Alaska, and the Gulf Coast, where shellfish harvesting is a cultural and economic cornerstone, face the greatest vulnerability. For many of these communities, no alternative industry of comparable scale exists.
| Region | Primary Species | Annual Revenue | Jobs Supported | Documented Acidification Impact |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pacific NW (OR, WA) | Pacific oyster | $278 million | 32,000 | 80% larval die-off (2007β2009); recurring failures |
| New England (ME, MA) | Atlantic sea scallop | $570 million | 48,000 | Shell thinning measured in scallop populations |
| Alaska | King crab, salmon | $1.4 billion | 62,000 | Crab shell weakening; pteropod decline in food chain |
| Gulf Coast (LA, TX, FL) | Eastern oyster, shrimp | $890 million | 51,000 | Nutrient runoff compounds acidification; oyster reef loss |
Which row in the table below correctly uses the economic data to describe the human impact of ocean acidification on U.S. coastal communities?
| Row | Most Vulnerable Region (by revenue) | Evidence of Current Impact | Projected Consequence |
|---|---|---|---|
| (1) | Alaska ($1.4B, 62,000 jobs) | Crab shell weakening; pteropod decline disrupting food chain | Economic losses could reach $400M/yr by 2060 without emissions reduction |
| (2) | Pacific NW ($278M, 32,000 jobs) | 80% larval die-off in hatcheries | Losses are projected to decrease to $75M/yr by 2060 |
| (3) | New England ($570M, 48,000 jobs) | No documented impacts on shellfish | Economic losses are expected to stabilize at current levels |
| (4) | Gulf Coast ($890M, 51,000 jobs) | Nutrient runoff has eliminated all oyster reefs | Reduced emissions would increase losses to $400M/yr |
A student analyzes the projected economic loss chart and makes the following observations.
Which set of observations are correctly supported by the data?
Coral reefs cover less than 1% of the ocean floor, yet they support approximately 25% of all marine fish species. Over 500 million people worldwide depend directly on coral reef ecosystems for food, income, and coastal protection. The total economic value of coral reef ecosystem services β including fisheries, tourism, coastal protection from storms, and pharmaceutical compounds β is estimated at $375 billion per year.
As ocean acidification progresses, scientists project that coral reefs will reach a tipping point where they dissolve faster than they grow. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) estimates that at 1.5Β°C of global warming, 70β90% of tropical coral reefs will be lost. At 2Β°C of warming, more than 99% are projected to disappear. For communities in Southeast Asia, the Pacific Islands, and the Caribbean, this is not an abstract environmental problem β it is a direct threat to survival.
| Ecosystem Service | Annual Value | People Directly Dependent | Most Vulnerable Regions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fisheries & food production | $6.8 billion | 500+ million | Southeast Asia, Pacific Islands |
| Tourism & recreation | $36 billion | 70+ million (jobs) | Caribbean, Australia, Red Sea |
| Coastal storm protection | $94 billion | 200+ million | Low-lying island nations |
| Pharmaceutical/biomedical | $5.7 billion | β | Global |
| Global Warming Scenario | Projected Coral Reef Loss | Approx. Ocean pH | COβ Concentration |
|---|---|---|---|
| Current (+1.2Β°C) | ~50% decline from 1980 levels | 8.05 | ~420 ppm |
| +1.5Β°C (Paris target) | 70β90% loss | ~8.00 | ~450 ppm |
| +2.0Β°C | >99% loss | ~7.95 | ~500 ppm |
| +3.0Β°C (current trajectory) | Functional extinction | ~7.85 | ~600 ppm |
Which row in the table below correctly describes the relationship between global warming, coral reef loss, and human impact based on the IPCC projections?
| Row | Warming Level | Reef Consequence | Impact on Human Populations |
|---|---|---|---|
| (1) | +1.5Β°C (Paris target) | 70β90% of reefs lost | Hundreds of millions lose coastal storm protection ($94B) and food sources ($6.8B) |
| (2) | +2.0Β°C | 50% of reefs recovered | Tourism revenue doubles as new reef species colonize warmer waters |
| (3) | +3.0Β°C | 70β90% of reefs lost | Pharmaceutical research expands to replace lost reef biodiversity |
| (4) | +1.5Β°C (Paris target) | >99% of reefs lost | Coastal protection services increase as reefs grow in warmer water |